Weak Recovery, Hypothesis Testing, and Mutual Information in Stochastic Block Models and Planted Factor Graphs

The stochastic block model is a canonical model of communities in random graphs. It was introduced in the social sciences and statistics as a model of communities, and in theoretical computer science as an average case model for graph partitioning problems under the name of the "planted partition model."Given a sparse stochastic block model, the two standard inference tasks are: (i) Weak recovery: can we estimate the communities with non-trivial overlap with the true communities? (ii) Detection/Hypothesis testing: can we distinguish if the sample was drawn from the block model or from a random graph with no community structure with probability tending to 1 as the graph size tends to infinity? In this work, we show that for sparse stochastic block models, the two inference tasks are equivalent except at a critical point. That is, weak recovery is information theoretically possible if and only if detection is possible. We thus find a strong connection between these two notions of inference for the model. We further prove that when detection is impossible, an explicit hypothesis test based on low-degree polynomials in the adjacency matrix of the observed graph achieves the optimal statistical power. This low-degree test is efficient as opposed to the likelihood ratio test, which is not known to be efficient. Moreover, we prove that the asymptotic mutual information between the observed network and the community structure exhibits a phase transition at the weak recovery threshold. Our results are proven in much broader settings including the hypergraph stochastic block models and general planted factor graphs. In these settings, we prove that the impossibility of weak recovery implies contiguity and provide a condition that guarantees the equivalence of weak recovery and detection.