TY - JOUR
T1 - Bayesianism, infinite decisions, and binding
AU - Arntzenius, Frank
AU - Elga, Adam
AU - Hawthorne, John
PY - 2004
Y1 - 2004
N2 - We pose and resolve several vexing decision theoretic puzzles. Some are variants of existing puzzles, such as 'Trumped' (Arntzenius and McCarthy 1997), 'Rouble trouble' (Arntzenius and Barrett 1999), 'The airtight Dutch book' (McGee 1999), and 'The two envelopes puzzle' (Broome 1999). Others are new. A unified resolution of the puzzles shows that Dutch book arguments have no force in infinite cases. It thereby provides evidence that reasonable utility functions may be unbounded and that reasonable credence functions need not be countably additive. The resolution also shows that when infinitely many decisions are involved, the difference between making the decisions simultaneously and making them sequentially can be the difference between riches and ruin. Finally, the resolution reveals a new way in which the ability to make binding commitments can save perfectly rational agents from sure losses.
AB - We pose and resolve several vexing decision theoretic puzzles. Some are variants of existing puzzles, such as 'Trumped' (Arntzenius and McCarthy 1997), 'Rouble trouble' (Arntzenius and Barrett 1999), 'The airtight Dutch book' (McGee 1999), and 'The two envelopes puzzle' (Broome 1999). Others are new. A unified resolution of the puzzles shows that Dutch book arguments have no force in infinite cases. It thereby provides evidence that reasonable utility functions may be unbounded and that reasonable credence functions need not be countably additive. The resolution also shows that when infinitely many decisions are involved, the difference between making the decisions simultaneously and making them sequentially can be the difference between riches and ruin. Finally, the resolution reveals a new way in which the ability to make binding commitments can save perfectly rational agents from sure losses.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=38549107479&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=38549107479&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1093/mind/113.450.251
DO - 10.1093/mind/113.450.251
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:38549107479
SN - 0026-4423
VL - 113
SP - 251
EP - 283
JO - Mind
JF - Mind
IS - 450
ER -